Rethinking philanthropy to meet Coloradans' urgent needs
© iStock
November is National Philanthropy Month and a new report from the Institute for Policy Studies spotlighted some flaws in the current system and offered insights for improvement.
In one example, researchers showed how money given through charity delivers tax breaks largely benefiting the nation’s wealthiest individuals and the tax breaks essentially take money out of government coffers needed to pay for food assistance, healthcare and other essentials.
Bella DeVaan, charity reform initiative director at the Institute for Policy Studies and the report's co-author, said up to 73 cents of each dollar donated by people with high wealth is subsidized by taxpayers.
© iStock - Mukhina1
"That's the total subsidy that wealthy donors derive from tax avoidance through their charitable donations. And so that's the trade-off, is that the money that they give is money that we could have received as a public," DeVaan explained.
The report’s recommendations included capping tax breaks for the wealthiest Americans. It also challenged major grantmakers’ decision to hold back their giving to legal minimums in order to grow their capital assets. Donor-advised funds, which account for 11 of America’s top 20 charities, have seen their assets grow by 475% in 16 years. DeVaan noted the money could be spent today in support of nonprofits, food banks and other front line groups.
The Stupski Foundation, which funds efforts to improve education, food justice and health, gets high marks in the report. The foundation is among the first to decide to give away all of its money and close its doors by 2029. DeVaan pointed out their strategy will inject hundreds of millions of dollars a year into work improving people’s lives.
"If you decide to shut down, you can accelerate and amplify your impact in the world by giving faster," DeVaan emphasized. "That's an example of how powerful it is when one person shifts their practices to be a bit bolder and the ways that it can catch on."
Another recommendation is to require minimum payouts keep pace with the growth of a foundation's endowment. DeVaan noted if the nation’s wealthiest charities distributed just 10% of their assets each year, it would unleash enough money to fully restore cuts to SNAP benefits made by congressional Republicans and provide a year of health coverage for over 560,000 people.
"That could unleash hundreds of billions of dollars over the next few years, from just a handful of institutions that have billions of dollars in their coffers already," DeVaan underscored.