Federal judge narrows lawsuit over Colorado semiautomatic firearm training law
A federal judge on Wednesday partially dismissed a lawsuit that seeks to block Colorado’s law requiring training to purchase most semiautomatic firearms. The new ruling follows an earlier decision against a preliminary injunction on parts of the statute.
The Colorado State Shooting Association and five of its members sued the state last year over the constitutionality of Senate Bill 25-3, which created a permit-to-purchase scheme for Coloradans to buy most semiautomatic guns that accept detachable magazines. In his recent order on the state’s motion to dismiss the suit, U.S. District Court Judge William J. Martinez dismissed significant portions of the association’s claim that the law is broadly unconstitutional.
“Plaintiffs’ facial challenge under the Second Amendment fails to overcome the presumption of constitutionality afforded to the (permit-to-purchase) shall-issue regime and fails at step one of the Bruen analysis,” he wrote, alluding to the landmark U.S. Supreme Court decision that established a standard to evaluate firearm regulations.
Facial challenges are legal claims that a law is unconstitutional in all circumstances.
The permit-to-purchase program in Colorado is presumed constitutional because authorities must allow prospective buyers the ability to purchase the guns in question if they meet a set of objective legal requirements — in this case, approval from a county sheriff, safety training and passage of an exam. Therefore, the shooting association and other plaintiffs would need to prove that the scheme is put toward “abusive ends,” and the wait times for classes and potential fees that they cited in their complaint do not meet that standard.
Readers wanting background on the law's origins can read about the 2025 House vote that advanced new semiautomatic firearm restrictions before the bill became law.
“Rather, a plaintiff must plausibly allege that the fees are sufficiently ‘exorbitant’ to effectively deny ordinary citizens their Second Amendment rights,” Martinez wrote.
© iStock - Josiah S
In August, the first month of the law’s major provisions, over 3,500 applications were submitted to a sheriff and 502 people passed the exam necessary to become eligible to buy the covered guns.
Martinez allowed the plaintiffs to continue with their “as-applied” claims, which concern how the law is allegedly unconstitutional in their specific circumstances. One is a disabled veteran, for example, and two others are frequent gun buyers who intend to buy one of the firearms covered by the law. The case is set for a jury trial next spring.
Martinez dismissed all the claims related to the law’s ban on rapid-fire trigger devices, determining that they are accessories rather than “arms” protected by the Second Amendment.
Neither the shooting association nor the lawyer representing the plaintiffs immediately responded to a request for comment.